Why Do People in a Company Hate Their Marketing Colleagues?

Introduction: The Love-Hate Relationship

Ah, the enigmatic world of marketing, a place where glittering events, creative campaigns, and artistic endeavours intersect with corporate strategy. It’s a field that often garners admiration and envy, yet also seems to attract a fair share of disdain, especially from within the very companies that rely on it.

So, why do people in a company sometimes hate their marketing colleagues?

Let’s delve into this complex love-hate relationship, exploring both the internal dynamics of a company and the external perceptions of the public.

Note:

This article features content from the Marketing Made Clear podcast. You can listen along to this episode on Spotify:

The External Perspective: Marketers as Villains

From the outside, marketers can often appear as the architects of consumer manipulation. They’re the ones behind those annoyingly catchy jingles, the relentless email campaigns, and the seemingly omnipresent ads that follow you around the internet. It’s no wonder that consumers sometimes view marketers with a mix of suspicion and irritation.

But let’s not forget, marketing is also about understanding consumer needs, creating value, and delivering messages that resonate. Despite the occasional misstep, marketers are often just as invested in creating positive experiences as they are in driving sales. However, the perception persists, and that negative public sentiment can seep into a company’s culture.

Internal Stakeholders: The Interdepartmental Friction

Within a company, the friction between marketing and other departments can be palpable. Let’s break down some of the reasons why:

1. The “They Don’t Do Anything” Myth

One of the most common complaints about marketers is that they don’t do anything substantial. Other departments, particularly those with more tangible outputs like product development or IT, might see marketing as a lot of talk with little action. “Oh, look at you swanning around at that event,” they’ll say, conveniently forgetting that those events are crucial for networking and brand visibility.

2. Upper Management’s Skepticism

Upper management can sometimes view marketing as a black hole for budgets. With ROI on marketing initiatives often harder to quantify than sales figures or production costs, executives might see marketing as an unnecessary expense rather than an investment. This perception can breed resentment and lead to tighter scrutiny of marketing activities.

3. The “Anyone Can Do It” Attitude

A particularly frustrating aspect for marketers is the notion that anyone can do their job. After all, how hard can it be to whip up a social media post or design a flyer? This underestimation of the skill, creativity, and strategic thinking involved in marketing can lead to dismissive attitudes and undervaluing of the marketing team’s contributions.

The Stereotypes: Fueling the Fire

Stereotypes are often at the heart of workplace banter, and marketing is no exception. Here are a few stereotypes that marketers frequently contend with:

1. The Bimbo

The idea that marketing is a haven for bimbos—superficial and lacking in substance—is an outdated yet persistent stereotype. While marketing does attract people who are personable and outgoing, it also requires a deep understanding of market dynamics, consumer behavior, and strategic planning.

2. The “People Person”

Marketing is often seen as more about people skills than substance. This stereotype can lead to the assumption that marketing lacks rigor and is more about schmoozing than delivering results. In reality, successful marketing is data-driven and requires a blend of analytical and creative skills.

The Banter: Harmless Fun or Crossing the Line?

Banter between departments can be a way to build camaraderie and defuse tension. However, it’s a fine line between playful teasing and crossing into offensive territory. As a director of marketing, I’ve had my fair share of jibes from colleagues in other departments. My counterpart in supply chain and I often exchange quips about each other’s fields, knowing it’s all in good fun.

Yet, not everyone sees it that way. I’ve landed in hot water more than once for bringing that level of banter into conversations with those who might not understand that it’s just a joke. It’s a reminder that while interdepartmental teasing can be a way to bond, it’s essential to be mindful of boundaries and perceptions.

Jealousy: The Root of Resentment?

Could jealousy be the underlying cause of the disdain towards marketers?

It’s possible.

Marketing often involves activities that seem glamorous from the outside—attending events, networking lunches, and creative brainstorming sessions. These aspects can be seen as the “good bits” of the job, leading others to believe that marketing is all fun and no work.

But every job has its challenges, and marketing is no different. The pressure to deliver results, the constant need to innovate, and the scrutiny from both within and outside the company can make marketing a demanding field. The perceived glamour is just one side of the coin.

Conclusion: Embracing the Love-Hate Dynamic

In the end, the love-hate relationship with marketing within a company is a complex interplay of perceptions, stereotypes, and realities. While it’s easy to see why marketing might attract some disdain, it’s also clear that much of it stems from misunderstandings and underappreciation of the value that marketing brings.

So, next time you’re tempted to roll your eyes at your marketing colleagues, take a moment to consider the intricacies of their work.

And marketers, remember to be patient and educate your peers about the strategic depth of your role. After all, a little understanding can go a long way in turning that love-hate relationship into one of mutual respect and collaboration.

Up Next:

Who Creates a Marketing Strategy?