The Controversies Surrounding Fireworks Night

Balancing Tradition and Modern Concerns

As marketers, we know that cultural events like Fireworks Night (or Guy Fawkes Night) offer significant opportunities for community engagement and brand connection. However, it’s essential to acknowledge the growing controversies around these celebrations, especially in an era where safety, sustainability, and social responsibility are paramount concerns for many consumers.

Fireworks Night, celebrated annually on November 5th in the UK, has deep historical roots, but in recent years, it has also sparked debate on various fronts. Below, we explore six key points of controversy surrounding Bonfire Night, and why marketers should be mindful of these when engaging with the event.

Sorry to be that guy… but it is kind of important!

Note:

This article features content from the Marketing Made Clear podcast. You can listen along to this episode on Spotify:

1. Fireworks Safety and Injuries

One of the most pressing concerns is the risk of injuries caused by fireworks. Despite increased awareness around safety, every year the NHS and emergency services deal with significant numbers of firework-related accidents. In 2022, around 1,000 people attended A&E in England for firework-related injuries during the four weeks around Bonfire Night. Disturbingly, children and teenagers are particularly vulnerable, with 30% of injuries involving under-18s.

The fire services also face immense pressure; during the 2021 Bonfire Night celebrations, London Fire Brigade dealt with over 1,000 firework-related incidents. This has led to increased calls for tighter regulations, such as limiting fireworks sales to licensed public displays. For marketers, this brings up questions about how to position campaigns, particularly those promoting safety or community values, while balancing the excitement of the event with its inherent risks.

2. Environmental Impact

Fireworks and bonfires can take a toll on the environment, contributing to air pollution and leaving behind waste. Fireworks release harmful particulate matter into the air, leading to spikes in pollution. For example, on November 5, 2020, UK pollution monitoring stations reported a 150% increase in PM10 levels – tiny particles that can penetrate the respiratory system and exacerbate health issues.

The environmental footprint doesn’t end with air pollution.

Fireworks leave behind litter such as plastic and metal debris, which can pollute waterways and harm wildlife. With rising consumer demand for sustainability, marketers should be aware of the growing backlash against environmentally harmful practices tied to traditional events. Brands looking to engage with Fireworks Night might benefit from promoting eco-friendly alternatives, such as laser shows or “quiet” fireworks that mitigate both noise and pollution.

3. Animal Welfare

For many, Bonfire Night is a night of fun and festivities, but for pets and wildlife, it can be a source of severe stress and fear. According to the RSPCA, 62% of dogs show signs of distress during fireworks displays. Animal charities receive hundreds of complaints each year about the effect of fireworks on pets, and owners often find themselves dealing with anxious and terrified animals.

The problem is exacerbated by the fact that fireworks are often set off not just on November 5th but throughout the autumn and winter, from October to January. This prolonged period of disturbance adds to the stress for animals and their owners alike. Brands promoting products or services related to pets or animal welfare may find opportunities to address this issue, offering solutions like calming pet products or promoting awareness around the impact of fireworks on animals.

4. Anti-Social Behaviour and Illegal Firework Use

Bonfire Night can unfortunately lead to spikes in anti-social behaviour. Incidents involving the reckless use of fireworks, such as setting them off in public spaces or dangerously close to people and property – are all too common. In 2020, there were around 17,000 reports of anti-social behaviour related to Bonfire Night, including illegal firework sales and underage use.

For marketers, particularly those working in community-focused sectors or local government, this raises the question of how to balance the excitement of Fireworks Night with the need for safety and social responsibility. Campaigns that promote safe and responsible celebrations, or that support local authorities in preventing anti-social behaviour, can help frame brands as proactive and community-minded.

5. Religious and Political Sensitivity

The origins of Bonfire Night are rooted in anti-Catholic sentiment, as it originally celebrated the failure of the Gunpowder Plot, an attempt by Catholic conspirators to overthrow the Protestant monarchy. While modern celebrations have largely shed their religious overtones, the historical context still lingers for some.

Burning effigies of Guy Fawkes remains a staple of the event, but in some cases, effigies of modern political figures have also been burned, sparking debates about whether the tradition perpetuates negativity or divisiveness. For brands operating in diverse markets, it’s essential to be aware of the historical sensitivities surrounding the event. Marketers should tread carefully when incorporating cultural symbols into campaigns to avoid alienating certain audiences or unintentionally promoting messages that could be perceived as offensive.

6. Calls for Firework Bans or Restrictions

Due to concerns about safety, environmental impact, and animal welfare, there have been increasing calls for stricter regulations on firework sales. A 2021 YouGov poll found that 57% of UK adults supported a ban on public firework sales, with fireworks only allowed at licensed, organised events. This reflects a growing trend towards more controlled, professional fireworks displays, as opposed to individual use.

For marketers, this potential shift in consumer attitudes presents an opportunity to align with changing preferences. Brands can consider sponsoring large, organized events that emphasize safety and environmental responsibility, while also promoting alternatives like light shows or eco-friendly fireworks. By supporting responsible and regulated celebrations, marketers can demonstrate their commitment to both tradition and contemporary concerns.

Conclusion: A Balanced Approach to Bonfire Night

While Bonfire Night remains a cherished tradition in the UK, it’s increasingly important for marketers to understand the controversies surrounding the event. Safety, environmental impact, animal welfare, and political sensitivities are all points of contention that can influence how people perceive the celebrations.

By taking a balanced, responsible approach, acknowledging the controversies while also offering solutions, marketers can position their brands as thoughtful, community-conscious, and forward-thinking. Whether you’re promoting an event, a product, or a service, understanding the evolving nature of Bonfire Night will be key to creating campaigns that resonate with today’s audiences.