The Great British Chocolate Wars: Cadbury, Mars & Rowntree

How Three Chocolate Giants Used Innovation, Storytelling and Strategy to Shape the Sweetest Marketing Battle in British History

This article explores the marketing and product development battles between three of Britain’s most iconic confectionery companies: Cadbury, Mars, and Rowntree.

We dive into their origins, innovation strategies, advertising masterstrokes, and the fierce rivalry that shaped not just the sweet tooth of a nation – but the blueprint of modern FMCG marketing.

The Marketing Made Clear Podcast

Check out the Marketing Made Clear Podcast on all good streaming platforms including Spotify:

Cadbury: Chocolate with Conscience

Founded in 1824 by John Cadbury, a Quaker and social reformer, the business began as a humble grocer’s shop in Birmingham, selling tea, coffee, and drinking chocolate. It was a time when alcohol abuse was rife, and Quakers – who disapproved of alcohol – encouraged alternative social stimulants. In that context, chocolate wasn’t just a treat; it was a moral proposition.

Cadbury’s early years were defined by this ethical framework. It wasn’t just about making money – it was about doing so without compromising people’s wellbeing. That ethos came to life most clearly in the creation of Bournville in 1893: a model village built to house factory workers in clean, green surroundings, far from the slums and smoke of industrial Birmingham.

It was a radical move, and an early forerunner of corporate social responsibility. Cadbury wasn’t just selling chocolate – it was offering a vision for a better society, blending commerce with compassion. This socially-driven narrative has underpinned the brand ever since, giving Cadbury a unique place in British hearts and homes.

Mars: The Ruthless Innovator

By contrast, Mars took a far more commercial – and secretive – route to the top. Founded in 1911 in Tacoma, Washington by Frank Mars, the company began by making buttercream candies in a small kitchen. It wasn’t until Forrest Mars Sr., Frank’s ambitious son, took the reins that the brand’s global destiny began to take shape.

In 1932, after a bitter fallout with his father, Forrest Mars Sr. moved to the UK and established Mars Limited in Slough. Here, he launched a new product tailored to British tastes – the Mars Bar, distinct from its American counterpart – and began building an empire. Forrest was meticulous, obsessed with efficiency, consistency, and innovation. He famously studied factory processes like a military general, believing that perfecting production was key to growth.

Unlike the Quaker values underpinning Cadbury and Rowntree, Mars was driven by commercial pragmatism and product-first thinking. There was no moral mission to lean on – just a relentless focus on making the best product, selling it at scale, and controlling the message tightly.

This single-mindedness would serve Mars well. It set the brand apart as the agile disruptor – willing to move fast, challenge tradition, and let the products do the talking.

Rowntree: Innovation with Integrity

Rowntree was established in York in 1862 by Henry Isaac Rowntree, another prominent Quaker. Like Cadbury, Rowntree’s early years were steeped in ethical values, with a commitment to worker welfare, education, and social reform. Henry’s brother, Joseph Rowntree, would later become a towering figure in UK philanthropy and social policy reform – founding trusts that still operate today.

But where Cadbury emphasised purity and wholesomeness, Rowntree doubled down on innovation and variety. Their approach was to create not just chocolate, but a whole suite of confectionery experiences. By the early 20th century, Rowntree had become known for inventing category-defining products that blended indulgence with accessibility – delivered through bold packaging and clever marketing.

They pioneered the idea of branded sweets, making products that weren’t just eaten, but remembered and loved – Smarties, Fruit Pastilles, and later, the mighty Kit Kat. The emphasis was on fun, imagination and breaking new ground – an approach that would set them apart from both the ethics-heavy Cadbury and the commercially steely Mars.

In Rowntree, you see the marriage of integrity and invention – a brand that wore its values on its sleeve, but wasn’t afraid to be bold, even playful, with its product development and brand positioning.

A Clash of Founding Philosophies

Together, these origin stories set the stage for decades of competition. Cadbury, with its moral compass and community ethos. Mars, with its commercial discipline and innovation engine. Rowntree, with its creative spark and ethical heritage.

Each company started from a different corner of the confectionery world – but all three would go on to shape how products are made, how they’re marketed, and how consumers emotionally connect with brands.

In many ways, their early strategies reflect the fundamental tensions marketers still wrestle with today:

  • Purpose vs profit

  • Emotion vs function

  • Brand heritage vs market disruption

The chocolate war wasn’t just about who made the tastiest bar. It was about whose worldview would win the hearts – and wallets – of the public.

Product Development: A Sweet Arms Race

The battle between these giants often hinged on who could invent the next big thing in chocolate. The innovation game was ruthless, experimental, and occasionally, chocolate-coated genius.

Cadbury: Creamy Consistency

Cadbury’s Dairy Milk launched in 1905, was a masterstroke. By increasing the milk content (more than rivals), they positioned the product as a premium treat. It was sold with a simple USP:

“a glass and a half of milk in every bar.”

This not only sold the product—it sold trust and quality.

They also innovated around seasonal products, arguably inventing the Easter egg marketing calendar. The Creme Egg, now synonymous with spring, first appeared in the 1920s and was refined into the gooey behemoth we know today in the 1960s.

Mars: Global Disruption

Mars played the long game. The original Mars Bar launched in the UK in 1932 – distinct from the American version. But it was the arrival of Galaxy in 1960 and the smooth branding of Maltesers that cemented Mars’ British foothold. They developed a taste for functional marketing – positioning products as energy-giving, such as the now infamous:

“A Mars a day helps you work, rest and play.”

It’s junk food spun like performance fuel – decades before Red Bull got involved.

Rowntree: The Risk-Takers

Rowntree arguably led in product innovation. Consider their impressive résumé:

Their strategy revolved around novelty and accessibility, often marketing sweets as fun, casual and shareable. Unlike Mars’ fuel-for-function approach, Rowntree went for everyday joy and playful branding.

Marketing Campaigns: From Storytelling to Sensory Seduction

Each brand developed a distinct marketing language, deeply entwined with British culture.

Cadbury: Emotional & Whimsical

Cadbury’s modern era has been defined by emotive storytelling.

Remember the drumming gorilla in 2007? Set to Phil Collins’ In The Air Tonight, it barely showed the product, yet became one of the most memorable adverts of the 21st century.

Why? It banked on emotional response over direct selling.

Before that, “Everyone’s a fruit and nutcase” and “The milk tray man” campaigns turned chocolate into a characterful experience. Their ads often leaned into whimsy and warmth, making them feel good without being saccharine.

Mars: Direct & Punchy

Mars built campaigns with clarity and repetition. Their slogans were rarely cryptic:

  • “Work, rest and play” for Mars Bars

  • “Melts in your mouth, not in your hands” for M&Ms

  • “Crispety, crunchety, peanut-buttery” for their imported Reese’s line (more recent UK work)

Their ads were benefit-first, built around product function, not abstract emotional concepts. It was FMCG marketing at its most rational-meets-indulgent.

Rowntree: Quirky & Conversational

Rowntree’s campaigns had charm and cheek.

“Have a break, have a Kit Kat”

…isn’t just a great slogan—it’s a cultural icon. Ads for Fruit Gums and Toffee Crisp often used humour and hyperbole.

They embraced sound and colour (Smarties were marketed for their “colour you can eat”) and leaned into sensory appeal in a way few others did at the time.

The Chocolate Cold War: Competition & Consolidation

The rivalry reached a boiling point in the 1980s, when globalisation and takeovers began reshaping the landscape:

  • Nestlé acquired Rowntree in 1988, taking one of Britain’s oldest sweet brands into Swiss hands.

  • Kraft Foods (later Mondelēz) took over Cadbury in 2010, sparking a political and consumer backlash over foreign ownership.

  • Mars, still privately owned, quietly continued expanding—acquiring brands like Wrigley and becoming the world’s largest confectioner.

Despite their differing styles, each brand competed on three key marketing fronts:

  • Shelf visibility (packaging and POS dominance)

  • Seasonal campaigns (Easter vs Halloween vs Christmas vs Back to School)

  • Brand emotion vs function (feel-good Cadbury, rational Mars, playful Rowntree)

What Marketers Can Learn

  1. Brand Heritage Can Be an Asset – But Only If It’s Alive
    Cadbury leaned into its past to build emotional capital. Mars leaned away to stay agile. Both were right, depending on context.

  2. Product Development Is Marketing
    Rowntree’s innovation pipeline wasn’t just NPD – it was marketing strategy in action. New formats, new flavours, new ideas = new customers.

  3. Slogans Still Matter
    “Work, rest and play.” “Have a break.” These weren’t just copywriting tricks – they were memory hooks for consumer behaviour.

  4. Emotional and Rational Both Work – If Executed Well
    From Cadbury’s drumming gorilla to Mars’ function-first copy, both storytelling styles worked when aligned with the brand’s core identity.

Final Thoughts

The battle of Cadbury, Mars and Rowntree wasn’t just about chocolate. It was a clash of philosophies: ethics vs function, emotion vs performance, British roots vs global reach. And it laid the groundwork for how modern marketing now operates in FMCG, branding, NPD and consumer behaviour.

For marketers, the war may be over – but the lessons still taste sweet.